My first two Butter Seattles (errr... London). I ordered Lady Muck with my Beautybar.com order last week, and picked up Victoriana at Ulta this weekend, since it was OOS at Beautybar.com. I used my $5 off $10 coupon at Ulta, so Victoriana came to a little over $9, which is still ok for my price range!
Butter London Lady Muck - 2 coats and omg, I LOVE this! The brush on this polish is quite thin, but it didn't cause me any trouble to apply.
Comparison with ChG Sea Spray: I saw a few comparisons of these two already before, and I was worried that I would need to purge SS, but I think they are different enough to own both! Perhaps my skintone makes them seem more different than they are.
Butter London Victoriana - 2 coats and I love this one as well! The brush on this bottle is significantly fluffier than the one on Lady Muck. I have no idea what that is about. I think I like the fluffier brush better, but now I have no idea which one is "right" and which one is "defective".
Comparison with RBL 360: I had read many times of 360 being compared to Victoriana, but never saw any pics myself. They are really quite different, but I can understand why similarities were drawn between the two. They are definitely in the same colour family. I love both, very much.
I picked up a total of 10 polishes this weekend and am, for the most part, quite pleased. I missed out on the fact that OPIs were still B2G1 at Ulta on Sunday so I could have picked up the entire POTC collection for $26+tax; instead, I ended up paying $32+tax for only 5 of the 6 polishes because I didn't know! I thought Ulta was putting out POTC the day after the B2G1 sale was over, but it turns out this wasn't the case :( It's kind of a crappy feeling to have missed out on a good deal! Oh well, at least I didn't crack during the week and order the collection online for >$40!